| Yearly Leaders | ||||||||||||||||
| Passing | ||||||||||||||||
| Year | Rating | Att | Comp | Pct | Yards | Int% | TD | Yds/Att | ||||||||
| 1964 | Billy Wade, Pitt | 87.3 | Bart Starr, MC | 430 | Bart Starr, MC | 245 | Charley Johnson, CL | 60.1% | Len Dawson, LC | 3200 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 2.3 | Len Dawson, LC | 30 | Jack Kemp, GW | 8.03 |
| 1965 | Rudy Bukich, WD | 88.9 | John Brodie, CL | 467 | John Brodie, CL | 290 | John Brodie, CL | 62.1% | Len Dawson, LC | 3570 | Rudy Bukich, WD | 2.1 | Len Dawson, LC John Brodie, CL |
25 | Len Dawson, LC | 8.38 |
| 1966 | Don Meredith, Dall | 88.5 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 489 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 267 | Bart Starr, MC | 57.0% | Len Dawson, LC | 3387 | Don Meredith, Dall | 2.1 | Joe Namath, WA | 23 | Don Meredith, Dall | 8.35 |
| 1967 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 93.5 | Len Dawson, LC | 485 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 285 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 63.3% | Len Dawson, LC | 3748 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 2.7 | Joe Namath, GN | 27 | Joe Namath, GN | 8.32 |
| 1968 | Len Dawson, LC | 100.8 | John Brodie, CL | 450 | John Brodie, CL | 239 | Bart Starr, MC | 61.5% | John Brodie, CL | 3127 | John Stofa, TS | 1.3 | Len Dawson, LC | 25 | Len Dawson, LC | 8.61 |
| 1969 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 98.5 | Johnny Unitas, ND | 473 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 286 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 62.0% | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 3851 | Sam Wyche, MN | 1.7 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 35 | Sonny Jurgensen, MR | 8.35 |
| 1970 | ||||||||||||||||
| Rushing | ||||||||||||||||
| Year | Att | Yards | Avg | TD | Long | |||||||||||
| 1964 | Jim Taylor, WD | 299 | Jim Taylor, WD | 1532 | Sid Blanks, GW | 5.6 | Jim Taylor, WD Jim Brown, AD |
13 | Jim Taylor, WD | 82 | ||||||
| 1965 | Jim Brown, AD | 301 | Jim Brown, AD Paul Lowe, HP |
1579 | Timmy Brown, TM | 5.8 | Paul Lowe, HP | 16 | Jim Brown, AD | 67 | ||||||
| 1966 | Gale Sayers, SP | 301 | Gale Sayers, SP | 1572 | Ernie Green, ND | 5.8 | Leroy Kelly, Dall | 10 | Leroy Kelly, Dall | 70 | ||||||
| 1967 | Hoyle Granger, GN | 281 | Hoyle Granger, GN | 1476 | Tom Matte, MR | 5.6 | Hoyle Granger, GN | 13 | Dave Osborn, Cin | 69 | ||||||
| 1968 | Leroy Kelly, Dall | 322 | Leroy Kelly, Dall | 1810 | Gale Sayers, SP | 6.5 | Leroy Kelly, Dall | 18 | Hoyle Granger, BC | 76 | ||||||
| 1969 | Larry Brown, CL | 251 | Larry Brown, CL | 1344 | Calvin Hill, Cin | 5.9 | Tom Matte, MR Warren McVea, MN |
11 | Wayne Patrick, V | 72 | ||||||
| 1970 | ||||||||||||||||
| Receiving | ||||||||||||||||
| Year | Rec | Yards | Avg | TD | Long | |||||||||||
| 1964 | Charley Taylor, Pitt Ron Kramer, SP |
75 | Art Powell, LC | 1227 | Art Powell, LC | 17.5 | Art Powell, LC | 11 | Hewritt
Dixon, HP Bernie Casey, MR |
76 | ||||||
| 1965 | Gary Ballman, MC | 85 | Gary Ballman, MC | 1146 | Bob Hayes, WD | 20.0 | Marlin McKeever, MC Johnny Morris, SP |
9 | Carroll Dale, ND | 80 | ||||||
| 1966 | Raymond Berry, SP | 77 | Clem Daniels, LC | 1106 | Otis Taylor, MN | 18.6 | Lance Alworth, WA | 12 | Jimmy Orr, Dall | 84 | ||||||
| 1967 | Homer Jones, SP | 95 | Homer Jones, SP | 1219 | Eric Crabtree, Alex | 17.6 | George Saur, MN | 11 | George Saur, MN | 80 | ||||||
| 1968 | Milt Morin, MC | 69 | Jim Hester, MR | 885 | Lance Alworth, BC | 18.3 | Milt Morin, MC | 10 | Bob Hayes, Cin | 80 | ||||||
| 1969 | Alvin Reed, HP | 85 | Alvin Reed, HP | 1099 | John Gilliam, MR | 18.5 | John Gilliam, MR | 11 | John W. Henderson, AD | 80 | ||||||
| 1970 | ||||||||||||||||
| Special Teams | Defense | |||||||||||||||
| Year | Scoring | Pts | Punting | Avg | Punt Return | Avg | Kick return | Avg | Interceptions | No | Sacks | No | Tackles | No | ||
| 1964 | Bruce Gossett, MC | 142 | Don Chandler, AM | 45.8 | Bruce Gossett, MC | 24.6 | Ode Burrell, MN | 37.7 | Tied by 3 | 6 | Willie Davis, AM | 18 | Sam Huff, Amarillo | 138 | ||
| 1965 | Jim Bakken, MR | 113 | Tommy Davis, MC | 45.5 | Pat Studstill, AD | 21.9 | Tom Watkins, CL | 31.0 | Kenny Graham, HP | 13 | Willie Davis, ND | 18 | Harry Jacobs, LC | 139 | ||
| 1966 | Sam Baker, Dall | 141 | Bob Scarpitto, MN | 45.3 | Kermit Alexander, TM | 14.4 | Gale Sayers, SP | 31.6 | Paul Krause, MR | 13 | Deacon Jones, Dall | 16 | Tommy Nobis, TM | 139 | ||
| 1967 | Sam Baker, Dall | 144 | Jim Norton, Alex | 44.6 | Hoyle Granger, GN | 22.0 | Travis Williams, CF | 39.3 | Charley King, HP George Saimes, GN |
9 | Bob Lilly, CF | 20 | Dennis Gaubatz, SP | 138 | ||
| 1968 | Jim Bakken, MR | 130 | Bill Van Heusen, Syd | 45.3 | Nolan Smith, HP | 21.9 | Preston Pearson, TM | 37.5 | Ed Meador, MC | 11 | Gerry Philbin, LC | 22 | Dennis Gaubatz, SP | 168 | ||
| 1969 | Erorl Mann, Dal Jim Turner, MN |
131 | Paul Maguire, MN | 46.3 | Lem Barney, TM | 13.8 | Bill Thompson, TS | 28.6 | Pat Fisher, CL | 8 | Deacon Jones, Dall | 16 | Nick Buoniconti | 144 | ||
| 1970 | ||||||||||||||||
| Team Legend | ||||||||||||||||
| Alex | Alexandria | |||||||||||||||
| AD | Adeline | |||||||||||||||
| AM | Amarillo | |||||||||||||||
| BC | Black Canyon | |||||||||||||||
| Dal | Dallas | |||||||||||||||
| Dra | Dracut | |||||||||||||||
| CF | Cape Fear | |||||||||||||||
| Cin | Cincinnati | |||||||||||||||
| CL | Crystal Lake | |||||||||||||||
| GN | Great Neck | |||||||||||||||
| GW | Great White | |||||||||||||||
| HP | High Plains | |||||||||||||||
| LC | Lancaster County | |||||||||||||||
| MN | Manhattan Nullifiers | |||||||||||||||
| MR | Manhattan Riflemen | |||||||||||||||
| MC | Motor City | |||||||||||||||
| ND | North Dallas | |||||||||||||||
| NH | Nags Head | |||||||||||||||
| PB | Pittsboro | |||||||||||||||
| Pitt | Pittsfield | |||||||||||||||
| SP | Severna Park | |||||||||||||||
| Syd | Sydney | |||||||||||||||
| TM | Temecula | |||||||||||||||
| TS | Tombstone | |||||||||||||||
| V | Vinton Avengers | |||||||||||||||
| WD | Wild | |||||||||||||||
| WA | Wantagh | |||||||||||||||