| 1966 | AFL | Draft | Picks |
| Round # 1 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Alexandria* | HB/KR/PR | Mike Garrett | KC |
| 2. Wantagh* | FB/HB | Hoyle Granger | HOU |
| 3. Great White | MLB | Garland Boyette | HOU |
| 4. High Plains | 1stDB | Emmitt Thomas | KC |
| 5. Lancaster | SE | Gary Garrison | SD |
| 6. Manhattan | HB/KR | Emerson Boozer | NYJ |
| Round #2 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | RT | Pat Holmes | HOU |
| 2. Alexandria | TE | Pete Lammons | NYJ |
| 3. Great White | CB | Ron Hall | BOS |
| 4. High Plains | LB | Rich Jackson | OAK |
| 5. Lancaster | LB | Wahoo McDaniel | NYJ |
| 6. Manhattan | DE | Aaron Brown | KC |
| Round #3 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | HB | Pete Banaszak | OAK |
| 2. Alexandria | OT | Terry Owens | SD |
| 3. Great White | QB | Don Trull | HOU |
| 4. High Plains | FB | Keith Lincoln | SD |
| 5. Lancaster | MLB | Chuck Allen | SD |
| 6. Manhattan | OT | Glenn Ray Hines | HOU |
| Round #4 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | DB-KR-PR | Rodger Bird | OAK |
| 2. Alexandria | DB-KR | Goldie Sellers | DEN |
| 3. Great White | DE | Dan Larose | DEN |
| 4. High Plains | LB | Paul Guidry | BUF |
| 5. Lancaster | MLB | Frank Emanuel | MIA |
| 6. Manhattan | LCB | Johnny Sample | NYJ |
| Round #5 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | P-K | Mike Eischeid | HOU |
| 2. Alexandria | F-SE | Eric Crabtree | DEN |
| 3. Great White | SE | Art Graham | BOS |
| 4. High Plains | QB | Pete Beathard | KC |
| 5. Lancaster | HB | Bobby Burnett | BUF |
| 6. Manhattan | FB | Billy Joe | MIA |
| Round #6 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | OT | Gary Kiner | SD |
| 2. Alexandria | OT | Dick Hudson | BUF |
| 3. Great White | FS | Howie Williams | OAK |
| 4. High Plains | OG | George Rice | HOU |
| 5. Lancaster | DT | George Gross | SD |
| 6. Manhattan | FB | Cookie Gilchrist | MIA |
| Round #7 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | OT | Jim Harvey | OAK |
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | QB | Max Choboian | DEN |
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | P-WR | Bob Scarpitto | DEN |
| Round #8 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | HB-PR | Ode Burrell | HOU |
| 2. Alexandria | DE | Ed Cooke | MIA |
| 3. Great White | P-QB | George Wilson Jr. | MIA |
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #9 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | TE | Bob McLeod | HOU |
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | OG | Joe O'Donnell | BUF |
| 4. High Plains | FB | John H. Johnson | HOU |
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #10 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | SE | Bobby Crockett | BUF |
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | OG | Al Reynolds | KC |
| 6. Manhattan | OLB | Bill Laskey | OAK |
| Round # 11 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | DB | Charlie King | BUF |
| 5. Lancaster | DB-KR-PR | Bob Neff | MIA |
| 6. Manhattan | RLB | Olan Underwood | HOU |
| Round #12 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | DT | Andrew Rice | KC |
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | OG | Pat Matson | DEN |
| Round #13 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | OT | Ernie Park | MIA |
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | TE | Dave Kocourek | MIA |
| Round #14 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | TE | Tom Mitchell | OAK |
| 4. High Plains | C | Larry Kaminski | DEN |
| 5. Lancaster | DE | Howard Kindig | SD |
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #15 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | LB | Tom Addison | BOS |
| 2. Alexandria | none | ||
| 3. Great White | PK | Gary Kroner | DEN |
| 4. High Plains | none | ||
| 5. Lancaster | C | Mike Hudock | MIA |
| 6. Manhattan | HB | Allen Smith | BUF |
| Round #16 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | none | ||
| 2. Alexandria | none | ||
| 3. Great White | WR | Carl Noonan | MIA |
| 4. High Plains | none | ||
| 5. Lancaster | FB | Bob Cappadonna | BOS |
| 6. Manhattan | LLB | John Baker | HOU |
| Round #17 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | none | ||
| 2. Alexandria | none | ||
| 3. Great White | RB | Pervis Atkins | |
| 4. High Plains | OT | Maxie Williams | |
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #18 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | none | ||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | none | ||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #19 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Round #20 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | none | ||
| Extra #1 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Extra #2 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Extra #3 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||
| Extra #4 | Pos. | Name | Team |
| 1. Wantagh | |||
| 2. Alexandria | |||
| 3. Great White | |||
| 4. High Plains | |||
| 5. Lancaster | |||
| 6. Manhattan | |||