| 333 491 |
| 3 10 1 |
1964
2nd
| Champion |
| 353 294 |
| Joe Smith |
| 9 5 0 |
1965
2nd
| 312 255 |
| Joe Smith |
1966
| 8 5 1 |
| * |
| Qualified for Post Season |
Lancaster County Fighting Amish
 | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  |
| Year Franchise Name W L T Pts F Pts A Coach Finish |
6th
| Joe Smith |
| * |
| * |
3rd
| 324 358 |
| Joe Smith |
1967
| 8 6 0 |
1st
| 378 142 |
| Joe Smith |
1968
| 13 0 1 |
| * |
2nd
| 294 296 |
| Joe Smith |
1969
| * |
| 9 3 2 |